Fish and other meat

[mikemaupin]

Hey fellows, is it better to smoke fish by itself or is it ok to mix it with other meats? Mike M

[West Coast Kansan]

I see no issues sliding fish in with meat other than ... The smoke flavor you want would be applied to both however so the flavor for the fish may be light on the beef.  I would not like fish with a strong smoke. I would also load the racks so any drippings miss each other.

[manxman]

When hot smoking I either put fish or meat in the BS for the reasons outlined by WCK. In particular I find it difficult to position the fish / meat so the drippings miss each other and also I find the cooking fish smell in particular seems to "cling" to anything else in the BS at the time.

Cold smoking is a different issue and the same problems don't arise, no drippings and with most cold smokes I tend to use either oak or apple for everything.

Just my opinion, sure others have a different viewpoint.  ;)

[3rensho]

In addition to what has been mentioned already, when hot smoking meat and fish I smoke them at very different temperatures (cooler for fish to avoid the white boogers).  For me that would preclude doing them together but to each their own.


Tom

[Habanero Smoker]

I agree with Manxman and 3rensho. I use different smoking temperatures and techniques when smoking fish, and drippings and aroma from either meat on fish, or fish on meat does alter the flavors of both.

[manxman]

when hot smoking meat and fish I smoke them at very different temperatures (cooler for fish to avoid the white boogers).  For me that would preclude doing them together but to each their own.

Another good point.  :)

[iceman]

I have to agree with all about keeping fish and meat seperate. Even the smoke coming off either one will taint the others flavor and give it an odd taste. ;)